Cookie monster ice cream recipe is an easy no churn treat to make. With two different types of cookies, this homemade ice cream will be a hit.

You don’t have to be a Sesame Street fan to enjoy Cookie Monster Ice Cream. It is so scrumptious and an easy to make ice cream recipe. Vanilla ice cream base combines with your favorite cookies, and more for a really tasty treat.

Our family loves homemade ice cream. They also love when I make Mint Chocolate Chip Ice Cream Cake,No Churn Vanilla Ice Cream, Peppermint Ice Cream and No Churn Cheesecake Ice Cream. You will love easy recipes that do not require an ice cream maker or ice cream machine. We even enjoy Pumpkin Ice Cream Recipe in the Fall.

Variation ideas
How to make cookie monster ice cream
Storage
Pro Tips
No Churn Ice Cream Recipes

What is Cookie monster ice cream?

This is such an easy ice cream recipe to make. Cookie lovers will go crazy over this ice cream flavor.

This delicious ice cream combines chocolate chip cookies and Oreo cookies with a creamy base. The ice cream is vanilla flavored and dyed with blue food coloring.

For more loaded ice cream treats, make Homemade Butterfinger Ice Cream.

Ingredients

heavy whipping cream
vanilla extract
sweetened condensed milk
Oreos, chopped into chunks of Oreo
chocolate chip cookies. We used Chips Ahoy Cookies.

Get the complete ingredient list and recipe in the recipe card at the bottom.

Variation ideas

Add edible cookie dough to the batter. I would add 1 cup to the mixture so there are enough cookie dough pieces.

Try different types of Oreo Cookies. Some ideas include peanut butter, birthday and more.

Substitute different types of Chocolate chip cookies. The kids like when I use the chips ahoy with M&M candy in the cookies.

Try other colors. While blue is the norm for this ice cream, you can use any color you prefer.

Make ice cream sandwiches. Save a few chocolate chip cookies and put ice cream in the middle.

Try only using one type of cookie. You don’t have to use both Oreo cookies and chocolate chip cookies. Feel free to use just one type of cookie.

Add sprinkles to the ice cream. Jazz up the recipe even more by adding sprinkles on top.

If you love chocolate, add mini chocolate chips. Just toss in a handful in the ice cream mixture.

Bowl with heavy cream, vanilla and food coloring.

Step 1. Use a stand mixer or electric mixer to combine the heavy cream, vanilla and food coloring in a large bowl. You will need to keep mixing until you see stiff peaks form. Next, add the sweetened condensed milk and mix until it is all combined together.

Cookie pieces mixed into ice cream base.

Step 2. Chop the cookies into small pieces. Then, fold them into the mixture. Save a few of the cookies to garnish the top of the ice cream.

Step 3. Put the ice cream mixture into a bread pan. Top with the remaining chopped cookies.

Step 4. Serve this creamy ice cream in ice cream cones or cups. Enjoy.

Storage

Cover the loaf pan of monster cookie ice cream in plastic wrap. I suggest also placing parchment paper directly on the ice cream. This helps to prevent ice crystals from forming.

Pro Tips

Make sure the cookies are crunchy and not soft. They will hold up better in the ice cream.

Freeze your mixing bowl. Chill this for a few minutes before using. This will help your whipping cream to have the best volume.

Store inside an airtight container to ensure freshness and avoid freezer burn. It will last up to a month stored properly.

Instead of chopping the cookies, you can use mini cookies. If you would rather skip a step, just use the mini chocolate chip cookies and mini oreo cookies instead.

No Churn Ice Cream Recipes

Make this easy recipe today and leave a comment. I love hearing from you.

Review Pin Print