22 Easy Thanksgiving Pie Recipes

We have gathered 22 easy Thanksgiving Pie Recipes. From Pumpkin, Pecan, to Oreo pudding pie all the flavors are covered. These classic pie recipes are easy to make with simple ingredients.

As the holiday approaches, I love making pies. I always make sure to have the classic pumpkin pie but I also love a good banana cream pie. We have 22 of The Best Thanksgiving Pies that are easy to make and will be a hit at your Thanksgiving dinner.

I love the Thanksgiving Holiday. It is all about the turkey, ham and the pies. Everyone has their favorite pie and it is a must that they see it on the dessert table.

We have been known to make pies year round. There is something about a good pear pie or a meringue pie.

Whether you like cream filled pie or fruit pies, we have you covered. Whatever type of pie filling you love, these Thanksgiving Pies will help you satisfy your sweet craving.

Thanksgiving dinner isn’t complete until you know what desserts were made. These Easy Thanksgiving pies are sure to please your family and your friends too.

You can even make Gluten Free Thanksgiving Pies.

What are the 2 most Popular Pies for Thanksgiving

The most popular pies for Thanksgiving are Pumpkin Pie and Pecan Pie. These classic desserts are both served with an easy buttery crust and then topped with whipped cream. You can even serve them a scoop of ice cream.

The Best Pies for Thanksgiving

We have many pies that we many for the holiday. We enjoy a caramel apple pie, maple pecan pie, or Dutch apple pie. Chocolate pie, bourbon pecan pie and lemon meringue pie are also on our dessert table.

Make sure to also have a coconut cream pie, classic apple slab pie or a delicious apple crumble. The combination of these ingredients really bring out the fall flavors.

1. Pecan Pie Recipe:

This is truly the perfect pecan pie recipe! It isn’t too sweet and just the perfect blend of pecans and more. This is truly the perfect pecan pie recipe! It isn’t too sweet and just the perfect blend of pecans and more.

Some recipes use crushed pecans but I have always preferred pies with the large pecan halves. This pie is really something special and I think you will agree!

2. No Bake Pumpkin Pie:

We make this every Thanksgiving or anytime we want a pumpkin dessert. It is so easy since it is a no bake pie recipe. You will love that it does not take any extra oven space.

Some recipes have a separate cool whip layer or even a cream cheese layer to make pumpkin cheesecake. We prefer this easy recipe that simply combines pumpkin pie mixture with whipped topping.

3. The Easiest Pumpkin Pie Recipe:

This easy pumpkin pie recipe is a family favorite. You can make this homemade pumpkin pie with just a few simple ingredients and very little effort. Once you try this amazing pie recipe, you won’t buy those frozen pies or bakery pies anymore.

This easy pumpkin pie is sure to impress. We love the flavors of the spice pumpkin seasoning that really brings the ingredients together as the pie bakes.

4. Sweet Potato Pie:

The pie filling is really creamy and the spices are perfect. It is the perfect blend and not overpowering at all. You can really taste the sweet potato and it’s delicious. This recipe is so easy and we have perfected the best combinations of everything.

This recipe is so delicious and easy to make for Thanksgiving, potlucks or any day of the week. If you normally make pumpkin pie, try something different and make this yummy sweet potato pie.

5. Chocolate Pecan Pie:

Pecan pie with a twist is so easy to make. The addition of chocolate really takes this pie up a level or two. I love classic pecan pie but this combination with chocolate is definitely something special.

The entire dessert is so decadent and has a fudge like center and lots of pecans on top. It is sinfully rich and even better with ice cream on top. I love it with a cup of hot coffee. It really is the best dessert or afternoon snack.

You don’t need a large slice because it is so decadent. A little definitely goes a long way.

6. Possum Pie:

This easy dessert with a unique name is rich and delicious. The entire recipe is so easy to make. If you have never tried it, it is absolutely amazing.

The pie consists of a decadent chocolate pudding layer and cream cheese mixture. All of this is layered in a pecan shortbread pie crust for even more flavor.

Everything is topped with whipped cream to make it even yummier. It comes together for the best dessert.

7. Crack Pie Recipe:

It is so easy to make at home and once you try it, you will be hooked. From the gooey filling to the large oatmeal cookie that makes the crust, this is nothing short of amazing.

Crack Pie is a delicious blend of butter, brown sugar, eggs and more. It comes together to form an ooey gooey topping on top of a huge oatmeal cookie crust.

The entire pie is coated in powdered sugar for a really decadent treat.

8. Oreo Pudding Pie:

Each bite of this luscious pie recipe is loaded with the best creamy filling. The no bake pudding mixture, crushed Oreo cookies and more combine for the best dessert.

From the pie to the topping, this recipe does not disappoint. The Oreo pie crust makes this even better. Every single bite is packed with tons of Oreo flavor. It is absolutely amazing.

9. No Bake Hershey Pie:

This No Bake Hershey Pie only requires 3 ingredients. It is easy to make and the perfect pie to make for all your holiday gathers. Hershey Pie is budget friendly and a time saver. Light, fluffy and full of chocolate flavor.

Everyone loves chocolate and this Hershey Pie is sure to be a hit. Everyone will want the recipe and be shocked when you tell them how little is required to make this amazing pie. Seriously it is that simple but the results are really impressive. 

10. No Bake Reese’s Peanut Butter Pie:

The pie has the best blend of peanut butter and the cream cheese and cool whip make it so fluffy and creamy. Just when you think it can’t get any better, the pie has Reese’s peanut butter cups on top and chocolate syrup! This peanut butter pie is seriously heavenly.

11. Salted Caramel No Bake Pie:

This easy no bake pie recipe is amazing. It is so creamy and just really decadent without much work. The salted caramel brings it all together for an unforgettable pie.

Whether you need a great dessert for a special occasion or just because, this pie does not disappoint. It is absolutely so delicious.

12. Keto Peanut Butter Pie:

This dessert is a great example of enjoying pie while staying on track with keto. I think you are really going to love this Keto Peanut Butter Pie. The consistency is so rich and creamy that it is almost hard to believe it is low carb. It is so amazing and I bet you will make this over and over.

13. Fried Apples Pies:

Fried pies never disappoint and make a great treat for any occasion. There is something special about fruit pies and everyone always loves them. We made apple pies but you can try other fillings. 

We have even tried cherry pie and cranberry pie because of the amazing fruit flavor.

14. Toffee Almond Pie

The flavors of the toffee and almond in this pie recipe is amazing. We like drizzle this with caramel sauce for a rich delicious pie.

15. Dulce de leche pumpkin pie

Serve this pie with a scoop of vanilla ice cream.

16. Butternut Squash Pie

This custard style pie is delicious and easy to make. The added cinnamon and sugar really combines the flavors.

17. Nutella Pie Recipe

We make this pie with Oreo Pie dough but you can choose what you prefer.

18. Butterscotch Pie

You can make this with a graham cracker crust.

19. Texas Pecan Pie

Delicious and easy to make pecan pie.

20. Apple Blueberry Pie

21. Butterscotch Pecan Pie

The corn syrup added really helps to combine the ingredients for a delicious pecan pie recipe.

22. Crustless Pumpkin Pie

Save on carbs with this delicious Thanksgiving pie recipe.

23. Paula Deen Pecan Pie

More Thanksgiving Desserts:

• The Best Oreo Turkey Cookies
• Easy Pumpkin Delight Recipe
• Pilgrim Hat Cookies
• Pumpkin Pie Cake